How Important is Physical Assisting in a Hatha Yoga Class?

Opinions about the importance of physically assistingour backs toward our students.
students, during Yoga posture (asana) practice, vary.Granted, some teachers have exceptional cueing skills,
Some styles, such as Iyengar, Restorative, Anusara,but when we are tempted to take our eyes off our
and Viniyoga, place much emphasis on properstudents, that is the time to work the room. There are
alignment, props, and physical assisting. Most Yogaother issues, in regard to assisting and adjusting. Be
teacher training programs focus on physical assists,sure you have asked for permission before adjusting
which guide a student toward proper alignment.anyone.
Yet, many students attend classes where a teacherSome students do not like to be assisted. If this is the
may not look at them for the entire class. Needless tocase, there is no need to ask why. They may feel that
say, there are no physical assists in these samean assist is an invasion of their space. In a case where
classes. Why? Some teachers feel verya student wants to be left alone, there is no need to
uncomfortable physically adjusting their student'spush the matter further.
posture. Some teachers are not trained to physicallyRecently, a Hatha Yoga teacher told me that physical
assist students during asana practice.adjustments were highly over rated. Curious about
There is also another factor to be considered: Therewhat was on his mind - I asked him to explain. His
are Yoga teachers who will not get off their mats.opinion was that while teachers "tinker" with a few
They do not walk around and monitor the room afterstudents, who have improper alignment, the rest are
demonstrating. Sometimes, we refer to this as:made to suffer by holding postures for minutes at a
"working the room."time.
One may think of "working the room" as it is related toWhile there is a ring of truth in the above-mentioned
a social butterfly, who constantly works on publicviewpoint, there is a reward of strength in holding
relations. Assisting is a bond between teacher andpostures beyond 20 seconds. There is also a method
student. Physical adjustments help any student to feelto avoid having students hold postures forever.
where he or she should be aligned, and to be presentThe method is to disguise repetition, by holding a
in the moment, while practicing asana.posture for five breaths, on each side, and coming
However, if we are in Downward Dog, with our backsback to the same, or a much similar posture, later in
to our students, how will we know if their posture isthe class. In this way, students are getting the most out
correct? It is obvious that we cannot see if ourof a session.
students are in good or poor alignment when we turn